Who is a producer? And who is a beat maker?

I Consider Myself A Producer In The Sense That I Can Direct A Person Or Group To Do Something That I Have In My Head.instuments And Gadgets Are The Means For Me To Do This....but With Out The Producer There Is No Production.....sure We Sometimes Multitask To Get Things Done..graphics,promos,etc. But The Name Producer In The Artistical Form Comes From Directing The Activities Of The Production...be It What It Is...no Matter What.in This Game The Name Is Tossed Around Greatly But If Youre Recording With A Producer Who After The Session You Know ..you Know..that The Song Came Out The Way It Did Cause Of That Person..then Yea That Guy Is A Producer...but If You Ask That Guy Questions About Your Mix And They Look As Dumbfounded As You Then Guess What You Need To Find The Real Deal. We Are All Talented People Who Are Just Trying To Perfect Our Skills Be What They Be.i Do Believe In The Point Of What This Post Is About. All Respect To Beatmakers, Musician's Designers,and Yes Producers, In The Original Sense.

I Consider Myself A Producer In The Sense That I Can Direct A Person Or Group To Do Something That I Have In My Head.instuments And Gadgets Are The Means For Me To Do This....but With Out The Producer There Is No Production.....sure We Sometimes Multitask To Get Things Done..graphics,promos,etc. But The Name Producer In The Artistical Form Comes From Directing The Activities Of The Production...be It What It Is...no Matter What.in This Game The Name Is Tossed Around Greatly But If Youre Recording With A Producer Who After The Session You Know ..you Know..that The Song Came Out The Way It Did Cause Of That Person..then Yea That Guy Is A Producer...but If You Ask That Guy Questions About Your Mix And They Look As Dumbfounded As You Then Guess What You Need To Find The Real Deal. We Are All Talented People Who Are Just Trying To Perfect Our Skills Be What They Be.i Do Believe In The Point Of What This Post Is About. All Respect To Beatmakers, Musician's Designers,and Yes Producers, In The Original Sense.